Monday, February 20, 2006

Iraq Intel: The Spy Who Failed Me


This article by Paul Pillar, a CIA Officer has-been, in Foreign Affairs is a must read.

Intelligence, Policy,and the War in Iraq
Paul R. Pillar
From Foreign Affairs, March/April 2006
"..... it has become clear that official intelligence analysis was not relied on in making even the most significant national security decisions, that intelligence was misused publicly to justify decisions already made, that damaging ill will developed between policymakers and intelligence officers, and that the intelligence community's own work was politicized ....."
This is quite an accusation. The author claims the mistake was not in the intelligence sector, but rather in the policy of not letting the UN inspectors do their work. War was rushed into. The messy aftermath was not thought through.

You don't go invade a country just because you can. With much power comes much responsibility.

I don't believe an immediate pullout of all troops is the answer. But the rush to war asks for some judgment. If you don't ask the questions, you are allowing yourself to be blackmailed.

Only a total spread of democracy in the Arab world will positively conclude the war on terror. I believe that. The question is, is the neocon Iraq way the way to go ahead, country after country? I don't believe so. It is too expensive in terms of lives and dollars, not sustainable. If the US had not so rushed to invade Iraq perhaps it might have found the better way to work towards the same goal.

Isolationist sounding liberals are not a viable alternative, so that neocons have failed is not enough solace. The answer lies with progressives who will find a way to spread democracy the progressive way while keeping the option of war as the weapon of the very last resort, and will reorganize flanks of the army for the new challenge of dealing with organized groups that do not fight with standing armies but rather through sneak attacks.

Bush has spent upwards of $200 billion on Iraq. A policy alternative would be to suggest perhaps a $10 billion war with communications technology and grassroots organizing should be fought, not that America should turn inwards. Isolationism is not an option, technically speaking. Globalization is here to stay. Or if you act miserly on the $10 billion proposal, you also lose another $1 trillion to Bush' tax cuts. So you spend $1o billion to save on $200 billion and $1 trillion.

And it is not just about spreading democracy in the Arab world. It also is about expanding the democracies in Europe and America so people of all cultural and religious backgrounds can feel at home in those democracies. Right now that happens not to be the case. This is also very much part and parcel of the war on terror. Xenophobes in the west are in the political target zone.

It is not just about introducing democracy in Arabia, but also about expanding democracy in Euro-America.

blac
The Larger WMD Question And Iran
Complicated Iraq
The Jyllands Posten Muhammad Cartoons Controversy
Pat Robertson Is Sick, Anti-Faith
French Society: No Easy Solutions

In The News

Update 2: US Envoy Warns Iraq Over Sectarian Govt Forbes
Five die in Iraq restaurant bomb BBC News, UK
Group begins month-long protest over Iraq invasion ABC Online, Australia
Bin Laden compares US tactics in Iraq to those of Saddam himself Salt Lake Tribune, United States
At Least 17 People Killed in Insurgent Attacks in Iraq New York Times, United States

Visitors

18 February04:47Verizon Online, Reston, United States

18 February08:01ONPT, Morocco
18 February10:25Road Runner, New York, United States
18 February11:06Smart Telecom Holdings, Ireland
18 February19:49American University, Washington, D.C., United States
18 February19:52Paknet Limited, Pakistan
18 February21:25Rogers Communications Inc., Canada
19 February00:19ETC, United Arab Emirates
19 February00:28Singapore Telecommunications Limited, Singapore
19 February01:44South Africa Internet Exchange, South Africa
19 February06:35Tele Danmark, Denmark
19 February11:01Level 3 Communications, Seattle, United States
19 February15:01Hungary (ceu.hu)
19 February21:32Alaska Communications Systems Inc., United States
19 February22:14Qwest, Bois D Arc, United States
19 February23:55Everest Connections, Kansas, United States
20 February00:33Xtra, New Zealand
20 February01:23Telia Network Services, Canada
20 February01:36Monash University, Australia
20 February02:17Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd, India
20 February03:02Multinet Karachi, Pakistan
20 February03:48World-Net Limited, New Zealand

20 February03:53TopLink Plannet GmbH, Germany
20 February05:04NTT Communications, Japan
Busiest day so far19 February 2006
Page views55

Contents 2004, 2005

The 90 Minute Experience
Presidential Primary Reform
The Spectrum On Gender
Pan American Desi Caucus: Brown Is Beautiful
Nepal Message To Top Democrats
Michelle Bachelet: Yet Another Woman
Lampson, Mistry, Dance-a-thon, LinkUp
DFNYC Socializing Is Circle 3 For Me
Mumzee's Kitchen
Soviet Health Care In America
Politics At The Speed Of Thought
Social Progress: Show Me The Money
Lee Metcalf Is A Naderite
Howard Dean's Anti War Email From Yesterday
Thanks David For Bringing Me Back To DFNYC
A Piece On DFNYC
Bill Clinton Is Now Anti War Like Dean
Short Stories
Social Security, School Vouchers, And Class Warfare
Superpower Talk, Infrastructure Talk
DFNYC, 100,000 Strong, Scalable Organization
Money, Message, Organization
The "I" Word: Monica And Saddam
Does Hell Have A Kitchen?
Pentagon, Hexagon
The Israeli Wall Is Wrong, Hillary
Howard Dean Is No Pacifist
Blacks, Hispanics At The Core Of The Democrat Rainbow Coalition
2006: When DFA Could Really Grow
The Spectrum/Dialogue Concept Is Key To Power
3 Bomb Blasts Each: London, Delhi, Jordan
38, 20
Congratulations Bloomberg, Now Switch Back Parties
DFNYC TV, DFNYC Wiki
Obama Was In Town And I Missed It
French Society: No Easy Solutions
Sick Sarkozy
Free Trade: Got To Walk and Chew Gum At The Same Time
Riots In France
Dick Cheney, Nelson Mandela, Howard Dean
My Involvement
Dean And Ferrer At City College
Atlanta
Blogging Is Scalable Media
First Mayoral Debate
Delhi Bomb Blasts
Say Hello To Appu
Mixer For Ferrer
American Leftonistas
Ferrer Gets Aggressive At A Ferrer Fundraiser
Mixing It For Ferrer
Bill Clinton Had Icecream For Lunch
Bill Clinton Has Left The Building
100 Hours Of Video Online Will Elect Ferrer
Jesse Jackson On Martin Luther King Boulevard
No Taxation Without Representation
Bloomberg
The Saudi Royal Family Has Got To Go
I Am Running For Dean 2008 Campaign Chair
50% Women Friends, 50% Women Colleagues
U2, Me Too
The One Voice Concept
Don't Need To Wait Till 2008
MeetUp, LinkUp
This Is What I Am Talking About
My Photo At ABCNews.com
The Bloomberg Machine
One Blog One LinkUp One Atom
Takes Two Arms And Two Legs To Swim
More On Organization
DFNYC And This Blog
Ferrer Can
Bloomberg: No Mr. Security
Messages To Dean, Ferrer
An Email From Headquarters
DFA Organization Framework
Soaking In Howard Dean
Lewis Cohen Has Been Behind Ferrer Since Summer 2004
Going On The Offensive For Ferrer
Who Is Leecia Eve?
2008: Some Themes
DFNYC In The News
Overheard In New York
2008: Some Thoughts
Dean 2008
A Not So Little Norman Fact
Dean Was In Town Yesterday
A Great Mixer
Bloomberg Is No Democrat
Fernando Ferrer
To: The Good White People In The South
Eric Cesnik For District 5
A Little Siegel Incident
Dean-Hillary-Obama Ticket
Democracy For Nepal, DFN
Landscape Talk
DFNYC Research And Advocacy Group
Simplifying Social Security Debate
Some Suggestions To The Cesnik Campaign
Eric Cesnik For City Council
Seceding
Dumb And Dumberer: Creationist Bush
Tracey Denton Of DFNYC
Hillary Speaks Up For NYC
The Three Pillars
Sister Blogs
I have written up a very long essay about the medi...
When Web Hosting Is No Longer A Problem